Delivery Obligation
YOUR company, Mountain States Rosen, is the largest supplier of American Lamb in the USA. Delivering good quality lamb to the Cooperative strengthens your company. Your delivery obligation is a tremendous asset for MSLC, and a cornerstone of the Cooperative’s business plan.
We encourage those with shares in excess of their own lamb numbers, or those who no longer market lambs to utilize the Co-op’s “Lease Pool” to help meet their delivery obligation. To place shares in the pool you must provide the office with written notification. It is a good idea to determine your delivery numbers and get those excess shares moved to the pool as early in the year as possible. Getting the shares committed to the lease pool does not guarantee they will be used, nor does it alleviate your responsibility if shares in the lease pool exceed demand.
It is crucial for you to meet your delivery obligation. While it is not our desire to take punitive action against any of our members it is the MSLC Board’s responsibility to protect the Co-op and make sure the Uniform Marketing Agreement is being honored.
While you have every right to sell lambs in excess of your MSLC Class A shares into the market of your choice we encourage our members to market ALL of their quality production through MSLC!
For 2009, we ask you to renew your commitment to MSLC, make every effort to meet your delivery obligation, and help us make Mountain States Rosen the successful venture you envisioned when we started this cooperative six years ago.
-MSLC Board of Directors

MSLC Delivery Policy
MSLC 2009 policy on nondelivery of lambs
The 95% rule: No Charge
If a member markets at least 95% of their annual delivery obligation through MSLC they will not be penalized for nondelivered shares.
The 75% rule: $1.00 per share fee
If a member markets at least 75%, but less than 95% of their annual delivery obligation through MSLC, they will be charged $1.00 per undelivered Class A share. Members may submit a waiver request to the MSLC Board for their shortfall. Each waiver will be handled on an individual basis, with penalties to be determined on a case-by-case basis.
The under 75% rule:$3.50 per share fee and/or penalties
Those members marketing less than 75% of their annual delivery obligation through MSLC will be charged $3.50 per undelivered Class A share, with possible additional penalties assessed. Members may submit a waiver request to the MSLC Board for their shortfall. Each waiver will be handled on an individual basis, with penalties to be determined on a case-by-case basis.
No Lambs delivered rule: $7.00 per share fee minimum
For any member that failed to market lambs through MSLC in the calendar year a $7.00 per share fee will be charged, with additional penalties possible if lambs are being marketed outside of the MSLC system or other factors dictate additional penalties are warranted.

Wyoming Producers Top August and Idaho Producers Top
September Grids
Wyoming producers, M Diamond and Philp Sheep Company, topped the Mountain States grid in August. M Diamond’s load was 78% Y2’s and earned a $4.77 average grid premium and a $5.54 natural premium for total average premium of $10.31 per head. These lambs were fed at Double J. M Diamond’s home is Glenrock, Wyoming and is owned by the Boner family.
Philp Sheep marketed a load of lambs that were 68% Y2’s. Fed by the Philp family, Shoshoni, WY, these lambs returned a market grid premium average of $4.24 per head and a natural premium of $4.89 for a total premium of $9.13 average per head.
During August the Idaho lambs dominated the grid. Lava Hot Springs producer, Henry Etcheverry topped the month with lambs yielding 82% Y2’s and 13% Y 3’s. This earned him a grid premium of $5.70 per head and a natural premium of $4.04 for a total average premium of $9.74 per head.
Frank Shirts of Wilder, ID sent a load of natural that were 86% Y2’s and earned a $5.40 per head grid premium and a $4.77 average natural premium for a combined average of $10.17 in premiums per head. |
 |
The following is an article from October 13, 2009 Meatingplace.com in which MSR’s CEO, Dennis Stiffler, PhD, discusses lamb marketing.
Lamb and veal processor touts marketing as key to success
Reprinted with permission from Meatingplace.com
By Ann Bagel Storck on 10/13/2009
Mountain States Rosen takes pride in its unique position as a U.S. lamb and veal processor that is completely vertically integrated. The company was created in 2003 as a joint venture between B. Rosen and Sons and the Mountain States Lamb Cooperative. Today it sources only U.S. lamb and veal from various western states and Pennsylvania and processes those animals at plants in the Bronx, N.Y., and Greeley, Colo., where it partners with JBS on the harvesting side of the business. With 2008 sales of about $150 million, Mountain States Rosen counts itself among the largest U.S. lamb and veal companies. Lamb comprises about 75 percent of its business, and its focus is largely on the retail market. That's good news in that at least the company isn't overly reliant on the struggling foodservice sector, but as CEO Dennis Stiffler explained to Meatingplace, Mountain States Rosen is committed to aggressive retail marketing to compete in a tough economic climate.
How have the U.S. lamb and veal markets trended overall in recent years?
You're probably looking at a $1.2 billion to $1.3 billion combined value of the lamb and veal markets. There has definitely been some decline in that market over the last 10 years. We track some things through FreshLook [Marketing Group for the retail market], and year to date for our last 52-week period, veal is down in dollars about 6.9 percent, and lamb is down about 2.3 percent. So the market is feeling some pressure as a premium, specialty market in this economy.
How can you make the higher price point of lamb and veal more palatable to retail consumers?
We look at lamb as a non-commodity product compared to what the poultry, beef and pork folks do. There's just a tremendous amount of protein, and it faces stiff competition for real estate at the retail counter. But being a unique product, if we can get [lamb and veal] into consumers' mouths and they can see the uniqueness of it, they'll come back for it.
What are the most promising areas of potential growth for lamb and veal right now?
Lamb, in particular, is a unique and distinctive product. It is under-developed in the marketplace. A lot of chefs have recognized its versatility and its positioning, the taste, the tenderness. I think the opportunity to position it is there. The key to that is making sure that your go-to-market strategy is such that you can get presence in that retail case and presence on that menu.
There's opportunity in emerging consumers. There are a lot of ethnic groups that are in the second and third generation, so they're becoming more westernized, if you will, and they're good lamb eaters. The real emerging markets are Middle Eastern, Indian, that cultural group. For years, and globally, they've been good lamb eaters. We've got to make sure our product is fitting their wants and needs.
We feel we can do that by having better category management and working more strongly with our retail partners so that we do have the product out there on the shelf. One of the things we've done on the East Coast in particular is develop a strong case-ready program. A large part of our growth in the past two to three years has been through having various technologies and using an assortment of packaging footprints so that the consumer can have a good selection of products to choose from.
Mountain States Rosen takes pride in its unique position as a U.S. lamb and veal processor that is completely vertically integrated.
How have the U.S. lamb and veal markets trended overall in recent years?
You're probably looking at a $1.2 billion to $1.3 billion combined value of the lamb and veal markets. There has definitely been some decline in that market over the last 10 years. We track some things through FreshLook [Marketing Group for the retail market], and year to date for our last 52-week period, veal is down in dollars about 6.9 percent, and lamb is down about 2.3 percent. So the market is feeling some pressure as a premium, specialty market in this economy.
How can you make the higher price point of lamb and veal more palatable to retail consumers?
We look at lamb as a non-commodity product compared to what the poultry, beef and pork folks do. There's just a tremendous amount of protein, and it faces stiff competition for real estate at the retail counter. But being a unique product, if we can get [lamb and veal] into consumers' mouths and they can see the uniqueness of it, they'll come back for it.
What are the most promising areas of potential growth for lamb and veal right now?
Lamb, in particular, is a unique and distinctive product. It is under-developed in the marketplace. A lot of chefs have recognized its versatility and its positioning, the taste, the tenderness. I think the opportunity to position it is there. The key to that is making sure that your go-to-market strategy is such that you can get presence in that retail case and presence on that menu.
There's opportunity in emerging consumers. There are a lot of ethnic groups that are in the second and third generation, so they're becoming more westernized, if you will, and they're good lamb eaters. The real emerging markets are Middle Eastern, Indian, that cultural group. For years, and globally, they've been good lamb eaters. We've got to make sure our product is fitting their wants and needs.
We feel we can do that by having better category management and working more strongly with our retail partners so that we do have the product out there on the shelf. One of the things we've done on the East Coast in particular is develop a strong case-ready program. A large part of our growth in the past two to three years has been through having various technologies and using an assortment of packaging footprints so that the consumer can have a good selection of products to choose from. |